top of page

A Candid Look: Your First Consultation Through the Eyes of a Criminal Defense Attorney


Welcome to a behind-the-scenes glimpse of the initial legal consultation from a perspective seldom shared – the attorney's. In this article, we're pulling back the curtain to reveal the human emotions, anticipations, and yes, even the anxieties that come with these critical first meetings. As an attorney dedicated to criminal defense, each new consultation is not just a professional encounter; it's a personal journey.


Section 1: The Attorney’s Preparation and Human Emotions

Before every consultation, there's a thorough preparation process. This isn't just about reviewing legal strategies; it's about preparing to meet someone new, someone who might be going through one of the toughest times in their life. We, as attorneys, feel a mix of excitement and nervousness. Will we be the right fit for their needs? How can we best help them? These questions aren't just professional considerations; they're human concerns.


Section 2: Building a Connection: More Than Just Law

The initial consultation is more than a legal meeting; it's the beginning of a relationship. Balancing professionalism with genuine empathy is key. Clients often expect a stoic, all-business demeanor, but they are usually pleasantly surprised to find warmth and understanding. We're trained to be confident, but we're human too. We understand the importance of building trust and making our clients feel at ease.


Let me share a personal experience. Some months ago, I had a young man in my office who had already had several lawyers represent him on the case for various reasons outside of his control. As I prepared for the consultation, I predicted that this client’s experience with so many other attorneys was going to have an impact on our meeting. I chose to start the meeting by just listening. I asked the client to share with me what his experience so far had been. While he shared his experience, I listened. I listened in a way that ensure the client knew I was listening. I maintained eye contact, I asked questions where appropriate, and most importantly when he shared something of a particularly sensitive nature, I made sure to thank him as I never take for granted how difficult it is to talk about sensitive subjects, particularly with relative strangers.


I knew the meeting was a success when the client told me he had never felt so listened to or comfortable that his lawyer was actually going to fight for him. After our meeting, I reflected on the importance of that initial connection. It's not just about the facts of the case; it's about establishing a relationship where the client feels valued and heard. This approach has become a cornerstone of my practice, underscoring the commitment to not only serve as a legal advocate but also as a trusted confidant from the very first consultation.


Section 3: The Dynamics of the Initial Consultation

During the consultation, we listen, we assess, but most importantly, we connect. While offering advice and outlining potential legal strategies, there's an undercurrent of mutual understanding. We're not just evaluating the case; we're getting to know each other. The client’s story isn't just a case file – it's a life, and we're here to defend it.


Section 4: Surprising Elements of Legal Consultations

Many clients are surprised by how invested we become in their cases. Each new client brings a new story, a new challenge, and a chance for us as attorneys to grow and learn. It's not just about the law; it's about people. And with people come emotions – not just from the client’s side but from ours as well.


Section 5: Reflections on Client Concerns and Attorney Anxieties

We understand the fears and concerns that come with facing the criminal system. These are feelings we empathize with deeply. Our aim is to not only address these fears legally but to connect on a human level. We share in the anxiety of uncertainty, the hope for a positive outcome, and the commitment to work tirelessly on our clients' behalf. Potential clients might not realize that while they are evaluating whether the lawyer is the right fit for them, the lawyer is also assessing whether or not they can effectively serve the client’s needs and whether the relationship will be a successful partnership.


I actually make it a practice to always meet with the potential client (if possible) before getting retained. You might be wondering, “How could you get retained without first meeting the client?” Well, it happens pretty regularly that an incarcerated person’s family will reach out to me to help their loved one. I always try to meet with the incarcerated person, the person who will actually be the client, before I get retained. It is vital that the client get a chance to feel me out and see if they are comfortable working with me. It is equally vital that I know who I am going to partner with before I commit myself to the case. This dynamic of a sort of mutual “job interview” in some ways is more like dating. It’s best to find out we are not a good fit for each other on the first date, than at the first wedding anniversary.


Frequently Asked Questions About Initial Legal Consultations


Q: What should I bring to my initial consultation?

A: It's helpful to bring any documents that pertain to your case, including any correspondence from law enforcement or the court, any bail papers, and a list of any questions or concerns you have.



Q: Will the details of our consultation remain confidential?

A: Absolutely. Attorney-client privilege ensures that what you share during our consultation is confidential and will not be disclosed outside of our legal team.



Q: How long does an initial consultation typically last?

A: Initial consultations generally last between 30 minutes to an hour. This gives us ample time to understand your situation and discuss your legal options.



Q: Is there a fee for the initial consultation?

A: Our firm's policy on consultation fees varies based on the type of case. Please contact our office directly for more information on consultation fees.



Q: What can I expect to learn from my initial consultation?

A: You can expect to gain an understanding of the legal aspects of your case, the potential outcomes, and the steps we would take to defend you. Our goal is to provide you with a clear path forward.



Q: What if I'm nervous about talking about my case?

A: It's perfectly normal to feel nervous about discussing your case. We strive to create a comfortable environment where you can feel safe and supported in sharing your story.



Q: How should I prepare for the consultation?

A: Consider writing down a timeline of events related to your case, any questions you have, and what you hope to achieve with legal representation. This preparation can help make the most of our time together.



Q: What if I decide not to hire an attorney after the consultation? 

A: The consultation is a no-obligation meeting. It's an opportunity for you to understand your legal situation better and for us to provide initial guidance. There's no pressure to make an immediate decision.



Q: Can I bring someone with me to the consultation?

A: You are welcome to bring a support person; however, be mindful that the presence of third parties can affect the confidentiality of the conversation under certain legal conditions.



Q: What sets your firm apart from others when it comes to criminal defense? 

A: Our firm prides itself on a personalized approach, where we not only defend your legal rights but also support you through the emotional challenges of the criminal justice process.



The initial consultation is a critical step in your legal journey. It's where professional expertise meets human empathy. If you're facing challenges within the criminal system and need someone who understands both the legal and emotional complexities, contact me to schedule a consultation. Let's navigate this path together.





12 views0 comments
bottom of page